VCS face-off: Why Developers choose Git over others


Brief Overview of Version Control System (VCS)

In software development, tracking and controlling changes to the source code is a critical process. A Version Control System (VCS) allows multiple developers to work concurrently on a project, manages modifications made to the codebase, and maintains a history of changes, making it possible to revert to a previous version if necessary. VCSs are integral to continuous integration and deployment, which are core tenets of modern software development practices.

What is Git?

Git is a free and open-source distributed version control system invented by Linus Torvalds in 2005. Git tracks changes in a collection of files, but what sets it apart from other VCSs is its non-linear and distributed nature. Git stores the project’s complete history and all version tracking information within the project directory itself, not in a separate place.

Why Choose Git?

Git’s Power of Distributed Version Control

Git is designed as a distributed VCS. This means that unlike a centralized version control system where there is a single, central copy of your project, Git gives every developer their own local repository, complete with a full history of commits. This drastically speeds up many operations, allows for offline work, and reduces the reliance on a single, vulnerable point of failure.

High-Level Performance, Security, and Flexibility

Git is built to be fast. Committing new changes, branching, merging, comparing past versions – all of these operations are performed locally, giving it a huge speed advantage on centralized systems. Git also employs the SHA1 cryptographic hash function, guaranteeing data integrity and protecting against information corruption or tampering.

Powerful Branching and Merging Capabilities

One of Git’s standout features is its branching capabilities. Branches are an integral part of working with Git. Other VCSs also have this feature, but the way Git handles branches makes it stand out. Making a new branch in Git is swift and effortless. Switching between branches is also quick and easy. These features make Git ideal for managing and maintaining multiple versions of a project.

Unmatched Repository Access and Integrity

Every Git directory on every computer is a full-fledged repository with a complete history and full version tracking abilities, independent of network access or a central server. This means you can be anywhere, anytime and still have a full backup of your project.

Pervasive Industry Adoption and Community Support

Git’s popularity means that help is always around the corner. A quick search or a post on a site like StackOverflow can usually solve any issues you encounter. The widespread adoption of Git also means that many third-party software tools and services are already integrated with Git, providing a smooth and cohesive workflow.

Detailed Comparison: Git vs Other VCSs

Git vs. Subversion (SVN)

Subversion (SVN) is a centralized version control system. Unlike Git, it doesn’t allow for local commits, and branching and merging are often more complex. SVN’s reliance on a central repository can also be a bottleneck, slowing down operations and posing a single point of failure.

Git vs. Mercurial

Mercurial is very similar to Git in terms of functionality but is often seen as easier to use. Despite this, Git’s robust functionality, flexibility, and widespread adoption often edge it out. For instance, while both systems allow for easy branching, Git branches are more robust and flexible.

Git vs. Perforce

Perforce uses a centralized model like SVN. As such, it suffers from the same drawbacks, such as slower operation speeds and a single point of failure. Git’s distributed nature allows it to outshine Perforce in areas of scalability, speed, and data redundancy.

Git vs. Concurrent Versions System (CVS)

CVS is an older centralized version control system. It doesn’t handle different versions of a project as effectively as Git and lacks the powerful branching and merging features that Git offers. Given Git’s superior capabilities and active development, CVS is largely considered a legacy system.

Git Integrations

Git and DevOps: A Symbiotic Relationship

Git fits perfectly into the DevOps philosophy of continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD). Git branches can be linked to specific stages in the DevOps lifecycle. For instance, a ‘develop’ branch can correspond to a staging server where changes are built and tested, while the ‘master’ branch can reflect the production-ready state of the application.

Git with Integrated Development Environments (IDEs)

Many modern IDEs like Visual Studio Code, Atom, and IntelliJ IDEA come with built-in Git integration, allowing you to perform Git operations from within the IDE itself. This can streamline the development process, making version control seamless and unobtrusive.

Case Studies

Successful Projects and Companies Using Git

Linux Kernel: The Linux Kernel, a project of massive scale with contributors from across the globe, has been using Git since its inception. Git’s distributed nature allows for an efficient workflow, where changes can be easily tracked, tested, and integrated.

Google: Google uses a modified version of Git called “Repo” for managing large codebases and coordinating code across a vast array of teams and projects.

Microsoft: Microsoft has been increasingly embracing Git. In 2017, they shifted their Windows development efforts to Git. Microsoft also owns GitHub, a popular online Git-based repository hosting service, providing further evidence of their confidence in Git.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is a Version Control System (VCS)?

A Version Control System (VCS) is a tool that helps software developers manage and track changes to their code. It allows multiple developers to work on the same code base without overwriting each other’s changes.

Git is a distributed VCS, meaning every developer has a complete copy of the project history on their local machine. This enables faster operations, offline work, and eliminates a single point of failure that exists in centralized VCSs. Also, Git’s powerful branching and merging capabilities set it apart from other VCSs.

A distributed version control system gives every developer a local copy of the entire project. This means developers have full project history on their local machine, enabling faster operations, offline work, and eliminating a single point of failure.

Branching in Git is fast and easy, which makes managing and maintaining multiple versions of a project more efficient. Switching between branches is also a straightforward task, and Git often automatically resolves different version conflicts.

Git enables efficient version control and collaboration, making it an integral part of continuous integration and deployment pipelines in the DevOps environment.

Many high-profile projects and companies use Git. For example, the Linux Kernel project, Google, Microsoft, and Facebook, among others.

Git’s features, combined with its widespread adoption and robust community support, make it a compelling choice. It’s a highly flexible and powerful system that can handle everything from small to very large projects with speed and efficiency.


Recap of Git’s Superior Features

From its inception, Git was designed to be a simple, flexible, yet powerful version control tool. It boasts impressive features like distributed version control, swift operations, robust data integrity, and remarkable support for parallel development.

Future Outlook and Closing Thoughts on Choosing Git as a VCS

With widespread industry adoption, continuous development, and a robust community, Git is set to remain the version control system of choice for many developers. If you haven’t already, it may be time to consider making the switch to Git.


  1. Chacon, S., & Straub, B. (2014). Pro Git. Apress. Link
  2. Torvalds, L., & Hamano, J. (2023). Git Documentation. Git. Link
  3. CollabNet VersionOne. (n.d.). Subversion (SVN) vs Git: Key Differences & Similarities. Link
  4. Atlassian. (n.d.). What is Git? Link
  5. Microsoft. (2017). Announcing Git Support for GVFS and Fastly. Link
  6. Eclipse Foundation. (n.d.). Git for Eclipse Users. Link
  7. GitHub. (n.d.). Hello World. Link
  8. Software Freedom Conservancy. (2023). Git User’s Manual. Link
  9. JetBrains. (n.d.). How to do everything with PhpStorm and Git. Link

Related Articles