Understanding Python’s ‘is’ Operator: Beyond Equality


Python is a popular programming language that provides several built-in operators for working with variables and values. One of these operators is the ‘is’ operator, which is used to test object identity. While it may seem similar to the equality operator ‘==’, the ‘is’ operator is actually quite different and can lead to unexpected results if not used properly.

Explanation of Python’s ‘is’ Operator

The ‘is’ operator in Python is used to check whether two objects are identical or not. It tests whether two variables refer to the same object in memory, rather than just checking if their values are equal.

This means that even if two objects have the same value, they may not be identical. For example, consider the following code snippet:

python a = [1, 2, 3]

b = [1, 2, 3] print(a == b) # Output: True

print(a is b) # Output: False

Here we have created two lists `a` and `b` with identical values.

The first print statement outputs `True` because both lists have the same values. However, the second print statement outputs `False` because `a` and `b` refer to different objects in memory.

Importance of Understanding its Functionality

It is important to understand how the ‘is’ operator works because it can affect your program’s behavior when comparing objects. If you use it incorrectly and rely on it for comparing object values instead of identity, your code will not behave as expected. In addition, understanding how ‘is’ differs from equality can also help improve performance in your program by reducing unnecessary comparisons between objects.

Brief Overview of What Will be Covered in the Article

This article will provide a comprehensive explanation of the ‘is’ operator in Python and its functionality. In addition, it will cover common pitfalls and misconceptions associated with its usage.

Furthermore, we’ll explore how to implement custom classes with ‘__eq__’and ‘__hash__’. By the end of this article, you will be equipped with a deeper understanding of Python’s ‘is’ operator and how to use it effectively in your programs.

Basic Understanding of ‘is’ Operator:

The ‘is’ operator is a built-in Python operator that allows you to compare object identities. At its core, the ‘is’ operator is used to determine whether two objects share the same memory address.

This means that when we say “x is y”, we are asking whether x and y refer to the same object in memory, rather than simply comparing their values. The syntax for using the ‘is’ operator is straightforward: simply place it between two objects that you want to compare.

For example, consider the following code:

x = [1, 2, 3] 

y = [1, 2, 3] z = x

print(x is y) # False print(x is z) # True

In this example, we create two lists (x and y) containing the same set of values. However, because they occupy different spaces in memory they are considered different objects with distinct identities. When we use the ‘is’ operator to compare them using “x is y”, it returns False since their identities don’t match.

Comparison with the ‘==’ Operator:

It’s important not to confuse the ‘is’ operator with Python’s equality (‘==’) operator. While both operators can be used for comparison purposes, they have different meanings behind them.

The equality (‘==’) operator compares object values instead of identity; it returns True if both objects have equivalent values regardless of their identities in memory.

x = [1 ,2 ,3] 

y = [1 ,2 ,3] print(x == y) # True

z = x print(x == z) # True

Examples to illustrate basic usage:

Let’s consider another example to better understand how basic usage of ‘is’ operator works.

x = 25 

y = 25 print(x is y) # True

x = "Hello" y = "Hello"

print(x is y) # True x = [1, 2, 3]

y = [1, 2, 3] print(x is y) # False

z = x print(x is z) # True

Here, we assigned the same value ’25’ and string ‘Hello’ to two variables which means that both will point to the same object in memory. Hence, when we use ‘is’ operator with these variables it will return True. In the next example, we defined two different lists with the same values and compared them using “is” operator which returns False since they have different identities.

in the last line of our code snippet , we create a new reference for variable x i.e. z=x (both now refer to the same object). When compared using ‘is’, it returns True as both references refer to the same memory location.

Beyond Equality: Understanding Object Identity

Explanation of Object Identity and How it Differs from Object Value

In Python, every object has a unique identity that is distinct from its value. The identity of an object is determined by its memory address, while the value of an object is the actual data it holds.

This means that two objects can have the same value but different identities. For instance, two integers with the same value will still have different identities because they are stored in different memory locations.

Understanding object identity is crucial because it allows for more precise comparisons between objects. When we compare objects using ‘==’, we are essentially checking whether they have the same value.

However, when we use the ‘is’ operator, we are checking whether they have the same identity. This makes a difference when dealing with mutable objects such as lists or dictionaries because their values can change over time, but their identities remain constant.

How The ‘is’ Operator is Used to Compare Object Identity

The ‘is’ operator in Python is used to compare the identities of two objects. It returns True if both operands refer to the same object and False otherwise. The syntax for using ‘is’ operator is simple: “`x is y“`.

Here x and y can be any valid Python expressions that evaluate to objects. It’s worth noting that not all types of objects support identity comparison in Python.

For example, immutable types such as integers or tuples always have a unique identity regardless of their values, so using the ‘is’ operator on them makes sense. On the other hand, mutable types such as lists or dictionaries may or may not share an identity depending on how they were created.

Examples to Illustrate Object Identity vs Object Value

Let’s look at some examples to differentiate between object identity and value:


a = 5 b = 5

print(a is b) # True because both a and b have the same identity x = [1, 2, 3]

y = [1, 2, 3] print(x == y) # True because both x and y have the same values

print(x is y) # False because they have different identities m = {'a': 1, 'b':2}

n = {'a': 1, 'b':2} print(m == n) # True because both m and n have the same key-value pairs

print(m is n) # False because m and n are different objects

Understanding object identity in Python is important for effectively comparing objects.

The ‘is’ operator checks whether two operands refer to the same object by comparing their memory addresses. It’s crucial to differentiate between object value and identity as they can be easily confused when dealing with mutable objects.

Common Pitfalls and Misconceptions

Common mistakes made when using the ‘is’ operator

One of the most common mistakes made when using Python’s ‘is’ operator is confusing it with the ‘==’ operator. While both operators are used to compare objects, they have different functionalities. The ‘==’ operator compares object values, while the ‘is’ operator compares object identity.

This means that even if two objects have the same value, they may have different identities and therefore not be equal according to the ‘is’ operator. Another common mistake is assuming that because an object was created with a certain value or name, it will always have that identity.

However, in some cases (such as with mutable objects), an object’s identity can change even if its value remains the same. It is important to keep this in mind when using the ‘is’ operator.

Misconceptions about its functionality and limitations

One key misconception about the ‘is’ operator is that it can be used interchangeably with the ‘==’ operator. As mentioned earlier, these operators have different functionalities and should not be used interchangeably. Additionally, some developers believe that using the ‘is’ operator can improve performance compared to using other comparison methods.

While this may be true in some cases, it should not be relied upon as a general rule. Another misconception is that all objects in Python share a single identity space.

This is not true – each process has its own identity space for objects created within it. Additionally, some built-in types (such as numbers) are implemented differently than other types and may behave differently when compared using the ‘is’ operator.

How to avoid these pitfalls and misconceptions

To avoid making common mistakes when using Python’s ‘is’ operator, it is important to first understand its functionality and limitations. Developers should take time to differentiate between the ‘is’ and ‘==’ operators and carefully consider which one is appropriate for a given use case.

It is also recommended to use the ‘is’ operator only when object identity is relevant, rather than relying on it as a general comparison method. To avoid misconceptions about the ‘is’ operator, developers should read the official documentation thoroughly and refer to reputable sources when learning about its functionality.

Additionally, it can be helpful to test code and experiment with various comparison methods to gain a better understanding of how they work in practice. By taking these steps, developers can use the ‘is’ operator effectively without falling prey to common pitfalls or misconceptions.

Advanced Usage: Implementing Custom Classes with ‘__eq__’ and ‘__hash__’

Comparison of Objects Using the ‘is’ Operator

As mentioned before, the ‘is’ operator compares object identity rather than object value. This means that it checks if two objects refer to the exact same location in memory.

When working with custom classes, this can become especially useful when trying to determine if two instances of a class are identical. For example, let’s say we have a custom class called Person that has attributes such as name, age, and occupation.

If we create two instances of Person – person1 and person2 – with the same attribute values but at different memory locations, using the ‘is’ operator will return False. However, using the ‘==’ operator will return True since both instances have identical attributes.

Comparing Object Value Using ‘__eq__’

While the ‘is’ operator is useful for comparing object identity, it is not useful for comparing object value. To compare object value in custom classes, you can define an ‘__eq__’ method that determines whether two objects are equal based on their attribute values. The ‘__eq__’ method takes in two parameters: self and other.

Self refers to the instance being compared while other refers to the instance being compared against. The method should return True if both instances have identical attribute values or False otherwise.

Continuing with our previous example of a Person class, we can create an ‘__eq__’ method that compares two instances based on their name attribute:

class Person:

def __init__(self, name): self.name = name

def __eq__(self, other): return self.name == other.name

Now if we create two instances of Person with different names but identical attribute values otherwise – person1 and person2 – using the ‘==’ operator will return False since the name attribute is different. However, if we use the ‘__eq__’ method to compare them, it will return True if both instances have the same name.

The Use of ‘__hash__’

The ‘__hash__’ method is used to generate a hash value for an instance of a custom class. Hash values are used in dictionaries and sets to quickly determine whether an object already exists in a collection.

When implementing the ‘__eq__’ method, it is also recommended to implement the ‘__hash__’ method. The ‘__hash__’ method should return a unique integer value for each instance of the class based on its attribute values.

Continuing with our previous example of a Person class, we can create a ‘__hash__’ method that generates a hash value based on the name attribute:

class Person:

def __init__(self, name): self.name = name

def __eq__(self, other): return self.name == other.name

def __hash__(self): return hash(self.name)

Now if we create two instances of Person with identical names but at different memory locations – person1 and person2 – using ‘==’ operator will return False since they refer to different memory locations. However, if we add them to a set or dictionary using their hash values generated by their respective “__hash__” methods they can be identified as identical objects.


After reading this article, you should now have a better understanding of Python’s ‘is’ operator and how it is used to compare object identity. By going beyond the basic concept of equality, you can take advantage of the full power of the ‘is’ operator and create more efficient code that deals with complex data structures.

Mastering Python’s ‘is’ operator can be challenging, but it is an important skill for any developer working with Python. Understanding how to compare object identity rather than just object value will allow you to write more efficient code and avoid common pitfalls and misconceptions.

So keep practicing with examples and don’t be afraid to experiment with custom classes. With patience and perseverance, you’ll soon be using Python’s ‘is’ operator like a pro!

Related Articles